by Laura Saxer
This month October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. On 13 October 2015, a social media campaign therefore called for a #NoBraDay encouraging women to post Selfies of their naked breasts in the name of breast cancer awareness. Instead of saving lives, such a campaign can rather be criticised for sexualising and trivialising breast cancer. Also, how is such a campaign supposed to be understood by breast cancer patients?
As a matter of fact there are no websites, organisations or charities affiliated with this campaign, so the interests behind it are very questionable. There is a big ongoing discussion of #NoBraDay in social media, and besides breasts you can also find critical posts like these:
“We are always appalled to see campaigns that claim to help women with breast cancer, but actually sexualise and objectify women’s breasts and bodies. But to see #NoBraDay take place on the same day as Metastatic Breast Cancer Awareness Day last week was especially horrific.” (Breast Cancer Action Facebook page)
“I’m not going to bother enumerating the many and varied ways on why this campaign is manipulative, ethically compromised, morally bankrupt, and personally insulting to me and the thousands of women like me for whom every day is #NoBraDay because breast cancer took our breasts. I am starting my own hashtags, my own campaign… #MastectomyAwareness or #ScarPride or #ShowUsYourNubs or #NoBreastsDay or #NoBreastSelfie.” (Kelly L. Gregory)
We have to consider that the categories and narratives people produce in the media define a social world that has consequences, for their own activities and the activities of others. Hence, the Internet is a space where opinions are formed, expressed and cemented.
Having this in mind, together with the example of #NoBraDay, we need to be critically aware of the narratives we are producing. Especially in social media where everyone can participate in, interpret and reinterpret social meanings, we should reflect upon what we actually want to address with our messages. Beyond the technological capabilities of publication, which can be a big plus in social media campaigns, there is also the important matter of audience.
When we think of the intended audience for Breast Cancer Awareness Month, is that audience interested in looking at naked breasts on #NoBraDay? Does looking at naked breasts in a social media campaign benefit this audience?
Blindly following global social media campaigns without questioning its practices and contributions can turn out to be quite awkward in the end. Breast cancer is definitely no issue to trivialise through such campaigns.
Shirky, C. (2010): The political power of social media technology, the public sphere, and political change, Foreign Affairs, 90(28).
#NoBraDay looks like one of those pointless “made-for-fun” things where one needs something “deep” to give meaning to it and render it acceptable – to the others or to oneself. The results are pretty questionable, as journalist Kate Dailey puts it: “how many of the viewers are talking about breast cancer, and how many are going to remember the breasts?”
I see this as a new type of slacktivism, which could deserve a brand-new name:
Pingback: Crap-tivism: a new baby for slacktivism? | New Media Frontiers
Eleni Rozali liked this on Facebook.
Jenn Warren liked this on Facebook.
Cornelia Saxer liked this on Facebook.
Connected4Peacebuilding liked this on Facebook.
Jeroen Brijs liked this on Facebook.
ShoutingBack: Using technology to #ShoutBack for gender equality liked this on Facebook.